By Kim Van Gorder | Reviewed by Dave Nava, Owner
Plow blades mark sealcoat. A steel edge scrapes the top film off the high spots every time it passes, and a blade that catches a raised manhole or a heaved crack can gouge the pavement under it. Some of that is normal winter wear. Who pays for the rest depends on what the snow contract says, and the contract can only settle it if the lot was photographed before the season. The fixes are mostly timing and equipment: seal early enough to cure in warm weather, set or mark every raised feature, and ask what is on the blade.
That is the short answer. Here is what actually causes the damage, what is normal and what is not, and how to keep the argument from happening at all.
Why fresh sealcoat and plows don’t mix

Sealcoat is a thin protective coating, not a new layer of pavement. It needs warm, dry weather to cure. Manufacturer data sheets call for surface and air temperatures of at least 50 degrees and rising, no drop below 50 degrees within 24 hours of application, and a full 24 hours of drying before vehicle traffic (SealMaster). That is why CMC’s sealcoat season on Long Island runs from about mid-April to mid-October.
Once winter arrives, every plow pass drags an edge across that coating. Plow makers say it directly: steel cutting edges can wear down sealant (BOSS Snowplow). That is also why a lot that gets plowed every storm sits at the short end of the normal 2-to-3-year sealcoat cycle.
Normal wear vs real damage
It helps to separate the two before anyone starts pointing fingers.
- Normal winter wear: sealer scuffed off the high spots, light blade marks across drive lanes, faded paint where plows turn. Expect it on any plowed lot. It is part of why lots get resealed and restriped.
- Real damage: gouges cut into the asphalt, broken curbs and island edges, catch basin frames or manhole rims knocked loose, wheel stops dragged out of place, sheared signs and bollards. That is what the damage clause in a snow contract is for.
What causes the worst damage
Most serious plow damage happens where the blade meets something sticking up: a manhole cover or catch basin frame set high, a speed bump, a wheel stop, a heaved crack edge, the corner of an island. Modern plows are built to ride over some of it. Trip-edge plows let the cutting edge fold back over obstacles under about six inches, such as manhole covers, large cracks, and speed bumps, and full-trip moldboards handle curbs and storm drains (BOSS Snowplow).
The cutting edge itself matters too, and there is a real trade-off:
- Steel clears closest to the pavement and is the hardest on sealcoat and markings.
- Poly or urethane is softer than steel and molds to the surface.
- Rubber causes “little, if any, damage” to the surface, but “it can also leave some residual snow and ice” (Fisher Engineering), which can mean more salt.
There is no free choice here. Gentler edges protect the surface and leave a little more behind. On a freshly sealed or freshly striped lot, that trade is often worth discussing with your snow contractor.
Striping takes a beating too
On highways, transportation departments have studied this for decades. Vermont’s research found that snowplow damage was “the single most deleterious factor” in the service life of thermoplastic markings, and that markings recessed slightly into the pavement survived intact (Vermont Agency of Transportation). Iowa guidance notes raised pavement markers belong in “areas without snowplowing” (Iowa State InTrans).
On a parking lot, the practical lessons are simple. Expect some plow wear on lines every winter, keep raised markers out of anywhere a plow goes, and plan the restripe for spring, after the last plow, so the fresh lines are not the first thing the blade finds.
Who pays
The contract decides. The industry’s procurement standard for snow services says a contract should “define the party responsible for repairing damages that were not identified in preseason photos and/or documented during a preseason walkthrough” (SIMA-10-2025).
So the honest answer to “who pays” is: whoever the contract says, judged against what the lot looked like before the first storm. Without dated photos, a broken curb in March is just an argument. With them, it is usually a short conversation. Our pre-winter photo record guide shows how to build that record in one walk.
Three lines worth having in writing:
- Who repairs damage that was not documented before the season.
- How and how fast damage gets reported after a storm.
- What counts as normal wear (sealer scuffs, faded paint) and what counts as damage (gouges, broken curbs, loose structures).
Want the before photos done right? A free CMC site walk photographs your lot before the first storm and goes over what we find with you. Request a free site walk.
How to avoid the fight
- Seal early enough to cure in warm weather. On Long Island that means scheduling sealcoat well before mid-October, so the coat cures while days are still warm.
- Fix raised structures in summer. Catch basin frames and manholes that sit high are what plows catch. Setting them to grade during patching or paving is cheaper than replacing them after a plow finds them.
- Close the cracks with plows in mind. Hot rubberized crackfill finished with a thin, low band lets blades pass over instead of tearing it out. See crack filling before winter.
- Stake everything that sticks up. Industry guidance is to stake catch basins, manholes, hydrants, utility boxes, pavement edges, medians, and parking islands in mid-fall (SIMA), and speed bumps too (SnowEx).
- Tell the snow contractor what is new. Freshly sealed or striped areas, new patches, new wheel stops. Ask what edges the trucks run and whether a gentler edge makes sense on the new work.
- Photograph before, walk after. A dated photo set before the first storm, and a walk together within 30 days after the season ends.
When one company does both
Most of the friction above comes from two companies working the same pavement without talking: one seals and stripes in the fall, another plows all winter, and in March each points at the other. CMC sealcoats, stripes, and plows. On lots where CMC does both, the crew running the plow in February knows where the fresh coat, the new lines, and the low crackfill bands are, and the lot was walked and photographed before the first storm. There is no second contractor to argue with.
If your lot is getting sealed, striped, or plowed this year, request a free site walk or call 516-735-2200.
Commercial sealcoating, line striping, and snow services on Long Island | CMConsite.com | 516-735-2200
FAQ
Manufacturers call for 24 hours of drying before traffic, at 50 degrees and rising. The bigger issue is curing in warm weather before winter, which on Long Island means sealing well before mid-October.
Light scuffs on high spots and drive lanes are normal winter wear on any plowed lot. Gouges in the asphalt, broken curbs, and loose structures are damage.
Whoever the snow contract says, judged against what the lot looked like before the season. Dated preseason photos and a written damage clause settle most disputes.
They reduce it. Rubber edges are much gentler on the surface but can leave a thin layer of snow and ice behind, which may mean more salt. It is a trade-off worth discussing for newly sealed or striped lots.
Plows wear paint every winter, especially where they turn. Expect some spring touch-up, keep raised markers out of plowed areas, and schedule major restriping after the last plow of the season.
Yes, if it can go down early enough to cure in warm weather. Fall sealcoat protects the surface through freeze-thaw season. A coat squeezed in too late, in cold weather, is what fails.
